The best cabin rentals in Mahoning Creek Lake, PA
The best cabin rentals in Mahoning Creek Lake, PA
Muddy Myst
1. Muddy Myst
99%
(333)
9mi from Mahoning Creek Lake · 4 sites · Tents, RVs, Lodging
Eco-Campsites and Recreation Area located in the heart of Western Pennsylvania! The site is in a great location, only a 12 minute drive from Buttermilk Falls and the Rails to Trails Bike Path that runs along the Allegheny River. For those interested in fishing we are only a short drive from Pine Creek, Cowanshannock Creek, Keystone Lake, Mahoning Dam, and Crooked Creek Lake. For those interested in off-roading, the Scrubgrass OHV park is only 20 minutes away.
Pets
Toilets
Campfires
from
$45
/ night
Neal Homestead Camp Sites
2. Neal Homestead Camp Sites
95%
(214)
17mi from Mahoning Creek Lake · 7 sites · Tents, RVs, Lodging
Camp is on 50 acres with a pink marked trail to Red Bank Creek on the western border and back up through a hemlock forest along south border. A small stream runs through the property and forms a rocky delta in Red Bank Creek. All camp sites are on the eastern border and close to the main road to access property. Hike, enjoy the sound of the stream tickling through property, stargaze, or rest, watch nature's critters, read or just relax in a hammock. No hunting on property but fishing permitted along "river" aka Red Bank Creek. Please keep fires in firepit and noise levels low. Set up to be most natural, minimal mowing, and sites meant to be more private. We let you know if you have others on property. No running water or flush toilets on sites unless in your self-contained camper. A compost loo provided. Lots of kindling can be easily gathered for a fire. Consider ordering some ahead of time if it has been raining though. There is a tarp and a wheelbarrow to collect logs and kindling and move to your site.
Pets
Toilets
Campfires
from
$18
/ night
Sunnyday's Forest
3. Sunnyday's Forest
97%
(76)
35mi from Mahoning Creek Lake · 2 sites
Just renovated for winter camping! Completely sealed up and draft free. Still a very primitive site, but the interior now keeps in the warmth from the fireplace. A set of bunk beds and a4 seat table as well as some could makes it work for up to 6 people. Plenty of tent area around of you have a bigger group!
Sunnyday's farm and forest was a Christmas tree farm in the 1950's. I've owned it for the last 30 years and it is now a horse farm with pastures and woods.
Rustic area of 25 acres of pastures and forest bordering a hundred of acres of railroad and municipal forest. Great for hiking, horseback riding, mountain biking. 1.5 miles from Deer Lakes park which has fishing, hiking, mountain biking, frisbee course and a great playground. The Allegheny river, judged to be one of the cleanest in the country, is just 6 miles away.
Harrison Hills park offers great hiking along the river and an occasional river otter.
The Rachel Carson Trail and Baker trail are just a few miles away.
It is a secluded log cabin in the woods on top of a hill overlooking a pasture. It is a very primitive cabin with a fireplace, brick floor, large porch, fabric interior and no chinking in the logs.
We provide a bunk bed and cots and 2 picnic tables..
There is a large grassy area in front of the cabin for tents.
There is no vehicle access, no electricity and no water at the cabin,
but LOTS of downed wood for fires. There are horses, goats, chickens, ducks and a pig that roam the pastures.
The cabin is about 300 yards from the parking area up a fairly steep hill, but the location is worth the walk!
If you're stopping with an RV or trailer we have ample parking near the road and have overnight accommodations for horses Great place for a stopover.
Pets
Toilets
Showers
from
$40
/ night
Tiny Home on the Hill
4. Tiny Home on the Hill
98%
(88)
39mi from Mahoning Creek Lake · 4 sites
Learn more about this land:
The TINY HOME features:
• 240 square feet plus sleeping for five. We have one queen sized and two single beds in the loft area. We have a comfortable single daybed on the first floor. We provide towels, comforters and pillows. We ask that Campers bring their own sheets or sleeping bags. House features a small kitchen and a full bathroom with a shower. We recommend short showers due to small hot water tanks.
• Electric fireplace, and a split unit provides air conditioning and heat.
• Refrigerator and electric stove.
• Large wooden covered front porch.
The SITE also features:
• Wooded trails
• Three fire pits with plentiful free firewood
• 250 square foot pavilion with picnic table.
• Trails thru woods plus large lawn area
OTHER:
We now accept pets. We charge $15.00 per pet per night. Pets must stay on the first floor.
• Recommend good tires, or 4 wheel drive to get up driveway, deflating tires may be necessary in bad weather.
• No Smoking Inside
Pets
Toilets
Showers
from
$84
/ night
The Nest - Creekfront Cabin In ANF
5. The Nest - Creekfront Cabin In ANF
99%
(67)
49mi from Mahoning Creek Lake · 1 site
"The Nest" presents a secluded cabin nestled along Tionesta Creek, situated in the heart of Allegheny National Forest. Offering complete privacy and serenity, this retreat boasts no visible neighbors, allowing guests to unwind amidst the tranquil sounds of nature and the babbling creek. With breathtaking views from every angle, visitors can anticipate sightings of eagles, blue heron, black bear, and other wildlife while savoring morning coffee on the deck. Additionally, guests have access to two kayaks to enhance their stay. The cabin comfortably accommodates five guests and features a full bathroom equipped with an off-grid water system, ensuring continuous access to hot water.
Parking for The Nest is along the widened shoulder of Route 666.
From the parking spot, an approximately 100 ft lightly sloped dirt foot path with stairs leads to the cabin. Nominal amount of firewood is provided for every guest.
Pets
Toilets
Showers
from
$125
/ night
Glamping Cabins in Cook Forest
6. Glamping Cabins in Cook Forest
28mi from Mahoning Creek Lake · 6 sites
Hominy Ridge Cabins and Gift Shop is located in Cook Forest State Park, PA, USA. Situated on 7 private acres, we offer 6 cabins (4 smaller ones with hot tubs) that offer most amenities. However, we do not supply bath towels and toiletries. We also permit dogs, for a $15 per day per dog fee, in most cabins with the exceptions to Cabins 1 and 3. Cabins 1, 3, 4, 6, all have private hot tubs on the porches. We do provide all bedding, pots, pans and dishes and silverware. Complete kitchens with all major appliances. Also provided is toilet paper, bath mat, dish soap, dish towels, scrub sponge, coffee filters with brew style coffee pot. We have firewood set up at cabins for convenience but the cost is $5 per bundle. Also, there is air conditioning for a $25 cost per day.
We have an onsite camp store that offers a wide array of items for camping, groceries, gifts, crafts, ice cream, tobacco, fishing bait and tackle, Pa Lottery, Pa Skills Machines, and so much more.
Pets
Toilets
Showers
from
$200
/ night
The River Otter Den - Riverfront!
7. The River Otter Den - Riverfront!
100%
(1)
28mi from Mahoning Creek Lake · 1 site
Tucked along the Allegheny River, our modern A-frame is a design-forward cabin blending cozy charm with contemporary style. Enjoy curated décor, a beautiful loft bedroom with cedar T&G ceilings, and stunning river views year-round. Sip coffee or wine on the deck, stargaze by the fire pit, and unwind in nature—just minutes from I-80 and near Emlenton and Foxburg. Perfect for kayaking, hiking, or simply escaping the noise.
Welcome to your peaceful getaway on the Allegheny River—this brand-new, custom-built cabin (completed in 2025) combines A-frame charm with elevated modern comforts. Nestled right along the riverbank, it features rich cedar tongue-and-groove ceilings, dramatic Iron Ore-colored walls, and thoughtfully designed interiors that feel cozy, stylish, and serene.
The layout includes two king bedrooms: one in the open loft above (ladder access with a 250lb weight limit), and a private platform king bedroom on the main floor—perfect for couples, friends, or a small group looking to escape. The full bathroom feels like a spa, with beautiful tile work, a walk-in shower, radiant in-floor heating, and even an overhead heater—all with peaceful river views from the shower.
Cook in the fully stocked kitchen with all the essentials, then relax in the cozy living space that opens onto a balcony with sweeping views of the Allegheny River—ideal for morning coffee or golden hour.
Grill a juicy burger on the propane Weber grill, then step down to the covered outdoor seating area with privacy fencing and a fire pit just a few feet away—your own hideaway for evening chats, s’mores, or stargazing.
Whether you’re here to unwind, explore, or just breathe a little deeper, this newly built cabin offers a peaceful, private escape with modern amenities and unforgettable views.
This property shares a driveway with two other cabins, one on either side. We’ve taken extra steps to preserve your privacy, including elevated window placement, privacy screens on outdoor spaces, and permanent balcony sides. You’ll also have direct access to the river, where you can fish from the bank, swim, or launch your kayaks.
Cancellation Fee Policy:
Please note that a 4% credit card cancellation fee will be applied.
Toilets
Showers
Campfires
from
$298
/ night
Piney Meadows Campground
8. Piney Meadows Campground
15mi from Mahoning Creek Lake · 43 sites
Welcome to Piney Meadows, a unique campground where families can create lasting memories in a beautiful outdoor setting. We are Dave and Tonya Aaron, proud parents of two wonderful children, with another on the way. Our love for the great outdoors inspired us to purchase this campground, allowing us to share our passion for nature with others.
Located right next to a fantastic ATV trail, Piney Meadows offers thrilling outdoor adventures for everyone. Dave, a lifelong resident of the area, fondly remembers the park during its glory days and is dedicated to revitalizing it into a fun and safe haven for families.
We invite you to join our community by liking our page to stay updated on exciting developments and events. We have many plans in store that you won’t want to miss! If you have any questions or suggestions, please feel free to reach out. We look forward to welcoming you to Piney Meadows, where adventure and family fun await!
L & M Campground
9. L & M Campground
27mi from Mahoning Creek Lake · 369 sites
Discover the charm of L&M Campground, a unique destination nestled just 3 miles from the expansive 2,981-acre Yellow Creek State Park in Indiana County, PA. Our campground stands out for its diverse range of camping options, catering to everyone from weekend adventurers to seasonal campers.
At L&M Campground, you can choose from a variety of sites, whether you prefer a cozy spot for a night or a more extended stay. Our amenities include a fully stocked camp store for all your essentials, a heated bathhouse accessible 24/7, and convenient laundry facilities available for a small fee. We also offer propane and firewood upon request to enhance your camping experience.
Whether you’re looking to unwind or embark on an adventure, L&M Campground is the perfect base for a fun-filled getaway. Enjoy activities such as fishing, boating, kayaking, swimming, and biking, or simply relax and soak in the natural beauty around you. With so much to offer, L&M Campground is your ideal retreat for a memorable outdoor experience!
Two Mile Run County Park
10. Two Mile Run County Park
46mi from Mahoning Creek Lake · 109 sites
Two Mile Run County Park stands out as a remarkable destination, encompassing nearly 2,695 acres of diverse landscapes and recreational opportunities. At the heart of this expansive park lies a stunning 144-acre lake, providing a picturesque setting for various outdoor activities.
With approximately 38 miles of well-maintained trails, Two Mile Run County Park is an ideal spot for hiking, biking, and exploring nature throughout the year. Visitors can immerse themselves in the beauty of the great outdoors, whether they are seeking a peaceful stroll or an invigorating adventure.
In addition to its scenic trails and tranquil lake, the park offers a range of amenities that enhance the outdoor experience. Families and friends can enjoy picnicking areas, fishing spots, and opportunities for wildlife observation. The park's natural features make it a perfect getaway for those looking to escape the hustle and bustle of everyday life while still being close to nearby attractions, including charming restaurants and local shops.
Woodland Campground
11. Woodland Campground
50mi from Mahoning Creek Lake · 43 sites
Discover a unique camping experience at our campground, where we offer a variety of accommodations including daily, weekly, monthly, and seasonal sites. Our full hook-up drive-thru sites are designed to accommodate even the largest RVs, while our shaded and open sites provide options for every preference. For those seeking a cozy retreat, we also feature charming family cabin rentals.
Enjoy the tranquility of our nearly 3-acre lake, perfect for fishing from the banks, dock, or one of our rental kayaks. Guests are welcome to bring their own kayaks or canoes (motors not permitted) to explore the serene waters. Families can take advantage of our playground and game room, which includes arcade games, a pool table, and a jukebox. Engage in friendly competition with a game of horseshoes or volleyball, or take a leisurely hike or bike ride along our scenic woodland trails. Don’t forget to let your furry friend enjoy some playtime in our off-leash area.
Our campground is conveniently located near a variety of attractions, including the Pennsylvania Elk Viewing and Visitors Center, the West Branch of the Susquehanna River, and Bilgers Rocks. Explore unique shopping opportunities, savor local cuisine at Denny’s Beer Barrel Pub, and indulge in the delights of nearby wineries.
Discover the most magical spots to pitch your tent or park your rig on your next Mahoning Creek Lake adventure.
Snag sold-out campsites.
Get notified the instant a national park campsite becomes available, for free.
See the best spots in one place.
Explore 500K+ public lands, RV resorts, and private sites you won't find anywhere else.
Book with confidence.
Read millions of real reviews from campers like you—so you know what to expect.Recent reviews from the Hipcamp community
Sarah-Rose
3 weeks ago
With pets
I loved camping at the tree house at Muddy Myst! The hosts were incredibly attentive to any questions we had during our stay and we were warm and cozy inside the cabin despite the chilly Temps outside. Our dog had the best time out of all 3 of us though! She was able to be off leash and run through the snow to her hearts content. We definitely will be back to make more memories here in the future 😊
See more
Melissa
3 weeks ago
Weekend Trip to The Nest - Creekfront Cabin In ANF
The views were great, we loved the location and being able to unplug! The cabin has mostly everything you need! We will definitely come back!
See more
Barbara
3 weeks ago
With pets
This was the perfect little space to get away from life in the winter. The little propane heater was enough to warm up the space in the middle of the night and early morning. I didn't have the right gear to hike in the snow but I will be back to try out the trails in the spring! There was plenty of fire wood and a solo stove which we didn't really use but I appreciate that it was available. Also the hosts were very friendly and offered extra lights and things to make my stay more cozy. I will most definitely be back with better gear ❤️ Thank you again for making this quiet space available for people to get away from the busy world!
See more
D
Dylan
3 weeks ago
With kids
Very helpful host, good land, & a peaceful stay. Would stay again & highly recommend.
See moreZ
Zack
January 2026
With pets
5/5 stars. If I had one word to describe it would be cozy. Ben is a great host. The cabin has nice privacy and it has everything you need utility wise. You are tucked away against a large creek if you like water activities. Nearby hiking trails. Check out the butcher shop in Sheffield if you like to grill!
See moreM
Mark
January 2026
With kids
Cabin was perfect! Kept us warm during a 13 degree night, animals were awesome for the kids and the outside fire pit was big enough to have a nice fire and to cook on… would definitely recommend
See more
Alex
December 2025
3 nights at Tiny Home on the Hill
Cozy, comfortable, and secluded. The owners were very accommodating and easy to communicate with. My dog, and I, loved the space of the surrounding area and hope to come again!
See moreBarbara
December 2025
With pets
I loved the cabin on the hilltop! It was very cozy with a wood stove and plenty of wood to keep us warm. The bunk beds were very comfortable and our host Gerry was very accommodating! We will definitely be back to explore more!
See more
C
Charlotte
December 2025
With pets
The loft in the trees was the perfect place to stay on a winter night but still be surrounded by nature. The outdoor mood lighting on the property perfectly highlighted the slow falling snow that welcomed my one night stay here. In the morning the land was peaceful with birds chirping and the creek bubbling slowly on my morning walk. The bathroom was Amazing!! Way better than anything I could have anticipated. This is a really well done Hipcamp and I would definitely stay here again. I appreciate Liam & Jolene for being so welcoming and for sharing such a wonderful space. My kitten loved being in the nature and away from cars and other people, thanks for having us!!
See more
A
Amber
December 2025
Weekend Trip to Muddy Myst
The cabin was clean, warm, cozy!! We enjoyed our stay.
Lookin forward to another stay in the summer. 💋🖤
See more
D
Dresden
December 2025
With pets
An absolute gem of a site. The cabin itself had everything we needed. Was already warmed up for us upon arrival on a snowy evening and held heat well throughout our weekend. Ben gave us a great hiking recommendation that we took advantage of and it was just what we were looking for. Enjoyed our evenings by the campfire and morning coffee on the steps by the river. Instructions were clear and easy to follow. We are already planning our next trip out here!
See moreM
Mohammad
November 2025
1 night at Muddy Myst
Easy to find, felt safe and comfortable! Provided everything we needed. Wish we got to enjoy more of the amenities, but we got the first snow of the season. Highly recommend!
See moreC
Carissa
November 2025
With pets
Muddy Myst was the perfect get away from the city. It gave such a comforting, safe and woodsy feeling. It was also very warm during a cold night! I would suggest this lovely place to anyone needing a cozy spot to relax!
See more
E
Emily
November 2025
Weekend Trip to The Nest - Creekfront Cabin In ANF
Incredible stay! The Nest allows you to disconnect and enjoy all of the beautiful nature around you. The host was phenomenal at communicating and I will definitely visit again in the future!
See more
Matthew
November 2025
Weekend Trip to The River Otter Den - Riverfront!
Amazing. From the view of the fall leaves and the Allegheny, to how nice the cabin was, to having a chimnied fire pit. Everything was perfect,. We usually do primitive sites, but I figured we could go glamping for once, and it was beyond anything I could expect. Meghan was super accommodating and a really nice host as well. 11/10 we'll definitely be back!
See moreS
Sarah
October 2025
3 nights at The Nest - Creekfront Cabin In ANF
This was the perfect spot to get away and unwind. The views are beautiful. We loved just listening to the creek. We would love to come back!
See moreE
Eva
October 2025
With pets
Very private . Nicely kept tiny home. Had everything we needed.
Bring sheets if sleeping bag and own towels. But I didn’t find that to be an issue. Great place for dogs as well.
See more
J
Jordan
October 2025
1 night at Muddy Myst
Fantastic property! We rented the tree cabin but the tent sites also looked great. All the amenities you could ask for while still being rustic and private. We visited for our annual fall leaf peeping trip, but we fully intend to come back in the summer--we are excited to take advantage of the cute little pond for swimming and kayaking.
Would highly recommend!!
See more
Erin
October 2025
With pets
We loved that this cabin was both small/rustic/affordable and still outfitted with all the big amenities. The heat, bathroom, TV, and cooking appliances were all fantastic, the outdoor area was spacious and the view down the creek from it lined up perfectly with the sunset! Had a great weekend exploring ANF from here, thanks!
See more
Barby
October 2025
Group trip
So peaceful and charming. Had the best weekend. Just bring your own sheets and food and everything else is provided. You will have an amazing time at this tiny house.
See moreBe the first to review
Share your experience here to help other campers.