I would definitely recommend Jug Handle Creek Farm. My husband and I stayed at site number 9 which was great and very private. One thing to keep in mind though is that the only water source (where the sink is located) is between sites 1 and 2 so if you are in sites 6-10 or so it's a bit of walk so I would make sure to bring a large lug or vessel to hold water so you aren't constantly going back and forth.

There was a big group while we were there staying in sites 1 & 2 that had basically monopolized the entire common use/sink area so we felt awkward every time we went to fill up our water. Besides that it was a great stay and we really enjoyed the hike and beach you can access from the campground.