Apple Hollow was an amazing stay! Not far from Zion NP, place was clean and well kept, and Nicole was a great host (prompt replies, welcome book provided, also provided us with wood for a camp fire.) Keep in mind that there are 4 tiny homes on the property that are relatively close (yet still quiet!). Great if you plan on going with other groups or families, yet still want some privacy.

Anne and Steve are incredible hosts! Steve gave us a fascinating tour of the mushroom farm, I recommend doing the tour and buying some mushrooms, they are delicious. It also rained on the last night and they offered us to stay at a small cabin of theirs that their summer intern usually stays in (we stayed there late October). It poured really hard and are so thankful for their kindness!!
We stayed at the further campsite the first night and it was perfect. You can drive right to the site. It was spacious and private. Steve mentioned that deer often come through the area but we didn't see any during our stay, but did see some on the drive close to the farm a couple of times. The other campsite is closer to the creek which also looked lovely.
The stay was close to many attractions. We went to Watkins glen, Robert treman, finger lake cider house, and Ithaca during the weekend. Overall, we recommend this stay!