12 Best Cabin Rentals Near Montauk, NY, US 2025

Beat the summer heat or the mid-winter blues with a quick cabin getaway outside New York City. No matter the time of year, you'll have your pick of Montauk cabins ranging from simple to sophisticated. A cabin rental near Montauk County Park or Hither Hills State Park practically writes your trip for you, with activities like saltwater fishing, horseback riding, and kayaking on the docket. If you'd rather get some R&R, try a peaceful log cabin or winter chalet by Lake Montauk. Alternatively, it's hard not to relax with a view of the Atlantic Ocean, though true solitude seekers may prefer the off-season—summer is when Suffolk County peaks. For the ultimate conversation starter, you can even bring your dog to a pet-friendly Montauk cabin.

97% (163)

Top-rated campgrounds

1. Humble Farm with Simplicity

96%

(212)

42mi from Montauk · 10 sites · Tents, RVs, Lodging · Higganum, CT

Bring your family and friends to camp at our quiet and very earthy and modest small family farm. Located in backwoods horse pastures with chickens, a dog, and a few horses. The property is very spread out and there are 2 outhouses for all sites to use. Your pets are welcome too! Locally there are state parks with beaches, and state forest for trails and lakes, hiking and biking. Or you can just relax and enjoy the serenity! OUR ADDRESS IS #200 NOT #204 Two parallel driveways THE DRIVEWAY TO THE LEFT FROM THE STREET IS OURS. Other attractions include local farmers markets, Millers Pond, Hammonassette State Park Beach, Gilette's Castle, with the famous River Ferry crossing the Connecticut River with a vehicle across to East Haddam at end of Rt. 148... We offer an hot H2O outdoor shower here for the comfort of out clients. It is located on the back of main house in corner. Entrance through gate is marked. Also See map in photos. We cannot allow any wood for camp fires to be brought in form the outside for environmental reasons. It can be pre-purchased for $12 per bundle on this site, or $10.00 cash here at farm. Farm Fresh eggs daily when available for $5.00 per 1/2 dozen. Blankets and pillows only are provided, NO LINENS for cabin or trailer sites only. Garbage removal is available as well $5 per bag provided.

Beat the summer heat or the mid-winter blues with a quick cabin getaway outside New York City. No matter the time of year, you'll have your pick of Montauk cabins ranging from simple to sophisticated. A cabin rental near Montauk County Park or Hither Hills State Park practically writes your trip for you, with activities like saltwater fishing, horseback riding, and kayaking on the docket. If you'd rather get some R&R, try a peaceful log cabin or winter chalet by Lake Montauk. Alternatively, it's hard not to relax with a view of the Atlantic Ocean, though true solitude seekers may prefer the off-season—summer is when Suffolk County peaks. For the ultimate conversation starter, you can even bring your dog to a pet-friendly Montauk cabin.

97% (163)

Top-rated campgrounds

1. Humble Farm with Simplicity

96%

(212)

42mi from Montauk · 10 sites · Tents, RVs, Lodging · Higganum, CT

Bring your family and friends to camp at our quiet and very earthy and modest small family farm. Located in backwoods horse pastures with chickens, a dog, and a few horses. The property is very spread out and there are 2 outhouses for all sites to use. Your pets are welcome too! Locally there are state parks with beaches, and state forest for trails and lakes, hiking and biking. Or you can just relax and enjoy the serenity! OUR ADDRESS IS #200 NOT #204 Two parallel driveways THE DRIVEWAY TO THE LEFT FROM THE STREET IS OURS. Other attractions include local farmers markets, Millers Pond, Hammonassette State Park Beach, Gilette's Castle, with the famous River Ferry crossing the Connecticut River with a vehicle across to East Haddam at end of Rt. 148... We offer an hot H2O outdoor shower here for the comfort of out clients. It is located on the back of main house in corner. Entrance through gate is marked. Also See map in photos. We cannot allow any wood for camp fires to be brought in form the outside for environmental reasons. It can be pre-purchased for $12 per bundle on this site, or $10.00 cash here at farm. Farm Fresh eggs daily when available for $5.00 per 1/2 dozen. Blankets and pillows only are provided, NO LINENS for cabin or trailer sites only. Garbage removal is available as well $5 per bag provided.

Public campgrounds near Montauk

92%

(19)

Stories from the community

K

Kornil

September 2025

Weekend Trip to Humble Farm with Simplicity

Great place and friendly people! Highly recommend!

R

Robert

August 2025

3 nights at Humble Farm with Simplicity

The property is beautiful and well maintained. Victor & Mary are wonderful and very accommodating. The Cozy Cabin is my favorite getaway.

R

Robert

July 2025

Weekend Trip to Humble Farm with Simplicity

Beautiful setting for a peaceful & relaxing retreat.

Sophie

July 2025

With pets

Weekend Trip to Humble Farm with Simplicity

We had such a nice time staying at Mary and Victor’s cabin! We brought our cat with us and we all got to watch the horses graze all day, had a perfect setup for fire and cooking. The bed was super comfortable and we slept amazingly. I would definitely recommend this place to others and we would love to come back and stay sometime soon. Victor and Mary were both extremely kind and welcoming, thank you for such a lovely stay!

D

Dhdnd

May 2025

Weekend Trip to Humble Farm with Simplicity

Great hospitality from Mary & Victor. The horses were friendly to my dog & I. There are also chickens on the site as well. You can tell a lot of thought was put into the cabin. It’s very homey & cozy. I stayed for one night and going to stay for more whenever I need a getaway! Recommend. :)

J

John

May 2025

Weekend Trip to Humble Farm with Simplicity

Mary and Víctor’s farm was exactly I was looking for, a place out of the city to connect with nature, Mary and Victor are an amazing hostess, I went with my dogs and they really had fun, I recommend this place, the best