The best cabin rentals near New Buffalo, Michigan with fishing

Looking for a fishing getaway in a cozy cabin near New Buffalo, Michigan? Hipcamp has over 70 options that meet your criteria. With top campsites like Heritage Farm Stay Adventure (196 reviews), CSC Permaculture Project (57 reviews), and Art Farm Fennville (59 reviews), you'll have no shortage of amazing places to choose from. Average price per night is $78 with options as low as $25. Popular amenities include campfires, showers, and pet-friendly accommodations. If you want to mix up your fishing excursion, popular activities in the area include biking, climbing, and horseback riding.

97% (234)

Top-rated campgrounds

Lake Nicholas. 12 acre totally private lake with great fishing. 36 feet deep.

Looking for a fishing getaway in a cozy cabin near New Buffalo, Michigan? Hipcamp has over 70 options that meet your criteria. With top campsites like Heritage Farm Stay Adventure (196 reviews), CSC Permaculture Project (57 reviews), and Art Farm Fennville (59 reviews), you'll have no shortage of amazing places to choose from. Average price per night is $78 with options as low as $25. Popular amenities include campfires, showers, and pet-friendly accommodations. If you want to mix up your fishing excursion, popular activities in the area include biking, climbing, and horseback riding.

97% (234)

Top-rated campgrounds

1. Have A Lake Of Your Own!

92%

(138)

47mi from New Buffalo · 10 sites · Tents, Lodging · Lawrence, MI

The property was originally owned by a family name Nichols (thus the name of the lake). It was handed down to the sons who each owned half the property. The driveway down the middle of property that leads to the lake was originally a fence line that divided the two pieces of property. The brothers did not get along and their are several stories of their warring on how to maintain the property.My parents bought this piece of property in 1964 and created a camp called "Lakeside Farm Camp", a small all boys camp. The camp has gone through several changes since then but has always been owned by the Edwards family. In 1984 the name was changed to "Cedar Lodge" a coed camp that specializes in English horseback riding and offering high level general camp activities. Enjoy the peace and quiet of our totally private fresh water lake. Take your boat out for a day of fishing or just chill next to the fire. Sites are approximately 50 feet from each other. If you want privacy we suggest you book both.

2. 20 Acre Woods

100%

(4)

45mi from New Buffalo · 1 site · Lodging · Lawrence, MI

Welcome to a secluded cedar wood built cabin (circa 1970) situated in southwest Michigan’s beautiful forest landscape. If you love being surrounded by nature this is the place for you. This is a place of reflection, enjoying the river , strolls through the property, bonfires, solace on the screened in porch. Learn more about this land: Traditional cedar wood cabin with some modern updates, nestled in 20 acres of native woods (maple, sycamore, beach, ash, walnut, paw paw), right on the Paw Paw river. Situated 2 hours from Chicago, 20 Acre Woods is the perfect place to retreat, reconnect with your humans and explore Van Buren County. Think camping/not camping . . . this is an original 1970's cabin with some modern updates - newly modeled kitchen, contemporary lighting, underfloor heating, filtered water system. You are situated on private land - secluded with easy access to local towns. You’ll find a map of the property parameters in the cabin. Local towns - Bangor (farm shop for fresh produce in season), Paw Paw (bakery boutique, kayaking), Watervilet & Coloma (kayak rental, outdoor movies in the summer, artes and craft store) Hiking, biking, cross country skiing on the Van Buren and Kal-Haven Trail. Other things to note when the weather allows, swimming in the river is lovely, just be prepared for the natural edge (clay/mud - river bottom is sand)

3. Potato Creek State Park

100%

(3)

365 sites · North Liberty, Indiana

Discover the natural beauty of Potato Creek State Park and its myriad of outdoor activities.

Pets

Potable water

Toilets

4. Tippecanoe River State Park

67%

(4)

182 sites · Winamac, Indiana

Discover Tippecanoe River State Park's scenic trails and historic charm.

Pets

Potable water

Toilets

Public campgrounds near New Buffalo

100%

(3)

Potato Creek Campground

26mi from New Buffalo · 365 sites · Tents, RVs · in Potato Creek State Park

67%

(4)

Tippecanoe River Campground

47mi from New Buffalo · 182 sites · Tents, RVs · in Tippecanoe River State Park

Stories from the community

E

Elizabeth

October 2025

Group trip

Weekend Trip to Have A Lake Of Your Own!

Great spot. We were the only cabin, so lots of privacy and the bathroom to ourselves. We rented a canoe and purchased firewood, they were ready and waiting upon our arrival. Lake was great to canoe around. Trail loop was short and sweet, but a nice walk through the woods. Seeing the horse get let out in the afternoon was really nice.

A

Anna

September 2025

With kids

Weekend Trip to Have A Lake Of Your Own!

We love this spot! Second time we have stayed and will be back!

A

Anna

September 2025

With pets

Weekend Trip to Have A Lake Of Your Own!

What a gem! We enjoyed our stay at Cedar Lodge so much—can’t wait to come back!

V

Viki

September 2025

With pets

Weekend Trip to Have A Lake Of Your Own!

We stayed in Penguin Palace. The cabin and campsite were clean and as expected. We enjoyed canoeing on the lake, relaxing by the fire pit, and peach picking nearby. I would recommend this place for a nice outdoor weekend!

J

Jake

June 2025

With pets

5 nights at Have A Lake Of Your Own!

The cabin was easy to get to but felt far away from the real world. We enjoyed having a fire in the pit every night and cooking our dinner and s'mores over it. The owner was always prompt and accessible for any questions we had. Would recommend if you're looking for a primitive cabin site.