The best forest cabin rentals near Fishers Island, New York

Looking for a cabin in the forest near Fishers Island, New York? Hipcamp has over 42 options that fit the bill. With an average price of $78 per night and options starting as low as $40, you're sure to find the perfect spot. Check out top campsites like Salamander Hollow Healing Habitat (194 reviews), Moon In The Pond Farm (100 reviews), and Vintage camper, wifi & firepit (68 reviews). Popular amenities include pets, toilets, and showers, while popular activities include whitewater paddling, surfing, and historic sites.

99% (166)

Top-rated campgrounds near Fishers Island

Looking for a cabin in the forest near Fishers Island, New York? Hipcamp has over 42 options that fit the bill. With an average price of $78 per night and options starting as low as $40, you're sure to find the perfect spot. Check out top campsites like Salamander Hollow Healing Habitat (194 reviews), Moon In The Pond Farm (100 reviews), and Vintage camper, wifi & firepit (68 reviews). Popular amenities include pets, toilets, and showers, while popular activities include whitewater paddling, surfing, and historic sites.

99% (166)

Top-rated campgrounds near Fishers Island

1. Humble Farm with Simplicity

96%

(213)

33mi from Fishers Island · 10 sites · Tents, RVs, Lodging

Bring your family and friends to camp at our quiet and very earthy and modest small family farm. Located in backwoods horse pastures with chickens, a dog, and a few horses. The property is very spread out and there are 2 outhouses for all sites to use. Your pets are welcome too! Locally there are state parks with beaches, and state forest for trails and lakes, hiking and biking. Or you can just relax and enjoy the serenity! OUR ADDRESS IS #200 NOT #204 Two parallel driveways THE DRIVEWAY TO THE LEFT FROM THE STREET IS OURS. Other attractions include local farmers markets, Millers Pond, Hammonassette State Park Beach, Gilette's Castle, with the famous River Ferry crossing the Connecticut River with a vehicle across to East Haddam at end of Rt. 148... We offer an hot H2O outdoor shower here for the comfort of out clients. It is located on the back of main house in corner. Entrance through gate is marked. Also See map in photos. We cannot allow any wood for camp fires to be brought in form the outside for environmental reasons. It can be pre-purchased for $12 per bundle on this site, or $10.00 cash here at farm. Farm Fresh eggs daily when available for $5.00 per 1/2 dozen. Blankets and pillows only are provided, NO LINENS for cabin or trailer sites only. Garbage removal is available as well $5 per bag provided.

2. Skunk Hollow

100%

(3)

45mi from Fishers Island · 1 site · Lodging

Secluded 30 acre lot with 3 cabins, two for sleeping and one is a kitchen cabin, fire pit and outhouse. Pond with paddle boat and brook on site. Access to hiking trails along the brook onto public land trust. Close to Brimfield, Westford hill distillery, Fenton Ruby wildlife reserve and other state parks. Enjoy dark nights and peaceful surroundings

3. Holiday Acres Campground

46mi from Fishers Island · 91 sites

Discover the charm of our unique campground in Scituate, Rhode Island, where nature enthusiasts can immerse themselves in the serene beauty of the great outdoors. Our campsite is designed to cater to campers and RVs of all sizes, ensuring a memorable experience for everyone, whether you’re a seasoned adventurer or a first-time camper. We encourage you to book your spot in advance, as our campground fills up quickly. Call us today to inquire about site availability, upcoming events, and entertainment options. We look forward to welcoming you soon! Families will appreciate our playground for kids and a recreation hall that hosts various social activities. Don’t forget to pack your fishing gear! Our lake is teeming with bass, catfish, and other fish, providing ample opportunities for a relaxing day by the water. Our RV sites come equipped with full hookups for water, electricity, and sewage, ensuring a comfortable stay. Enjoy the privacy and tranquility of our spacious grounds, complete with fire pits, picnic tables, and clean restroom facilities. With a nearby beach and open fields, there’s plenty of space to explore and unwind. Plan your next outdoor adventure with us and experience all that our beautiful campsite has to offer!

4. Pachaug State Forest

70%

(5)

62 sites · Jewett City, Connecticut

Pachaug is Connecticut’s largest state forest, clocking in at twodozen acres. Oh wait, excuse us, two-dozen-thousand acres! That’s 24,000 for the non-bakers here. Long story short, it’s going to take a loooong time to explore this whole place. Pachaug is derived from the Indian term meaning bend or turn in the river. Unsurprisingly, the Pachaug River is one twisty son-of-a…headwater, probably. Anyways, this makes for excellent boating and the fish seem to like it too, if you catch our drift. And why wouldn’t they? This place is something else.

Pets

Electrical hookup

Toilets

5. West Thompson Lake

24 sites · North Grosvenor Dale, Connecticut

Famous bass and trout fishing and winter snowmobiling?! West Thompson Lake is classic Connecticut, with lots to do and real seasons that affect when you can do it. In addition to summertime anglin' and wintertime snow blasting, there's seasonal hunting and epic autumnal leaf displays. Once you're out here you'll have a hard time believing you're within two hours of Boston, Providence, and Hartford. You'd better believe there's hiking, boating, and camping of every type so the whole family can experience nature in the northeast within an easy drive of the city.

Pets

Toilets

Campfires

6. Acorn Acres Campground

22mi from Fishers Island · 45 sites

Acorn Acres Campground stands out as a year-round destination in Southeastern Connecticut, nestled within 100 picturesque wooded acres. This unique campground caters to every type of camper, offering a variety of accommodations from full-service sites for large RVs and campers to cozy tent sites. For those who prefer a more comfortable stay, we also provide four charming cabins, ensuring that everyone can enjoy a memorable vacation with us. Our expansive grounds feature spacious areas perfect for group gatherings, as well as secluded spots for campers seeking tranquility and privacy. At Acorn Acres, we pride ourselves on being a “camper-centric” campground, dedicated to exceeding your expectations and creating an unforgettable camping experience. Whether your goal is family fun or peaceful relaxation, we have everything you need to make your stay enjoyable. Come explore the beauty of nature, engage in outdoor activities, and discover nearby attractions, including swimming holes, restaurants, and shops. We can’t wait to welcome you!

Public campgrounds near Fishers Island

Legend Wood Shelter

16mi from Fishers Island · 1 site · in Pachaug State Forest

Peg Mill Shelter

20mi from Fishers Island · 1 site · in Pachaug State Forest

Dry Reservoir Shelter

22mi from Fishers Island · 1 site · in Pachaug State Forest

Dawley Pond Shelter

25mi from Fishers Island · 1 site · in Pachaug State Forest

West Thompson Lake Campground

47mi from Fishers Island · 24 sites · Tents, RVs · in West Thompson Lake

Recent reviews from the Hipcamp community

K

Kornil

September 2025

Weekend Trip to Humble Farm with Simplicity

Great place and friendly people! Highly recommend!

R

Robert

August 2025

3 nights at Humble Farm with Simplicity

The property is beautiful and well maintained. Victor & Mary are wonderful and very accommodating. The Cozy Cabin is my favorite getaway.

R

Robert

July 2025

Weekend Trip to Humble Farm with Simplicity

Beautiful setting for a peaceful & relaxing retreat.

Sophie

July 2025

With pets

Weekend Trip to Humble Farm with Simplicity

We had such a nice time staying at Mary and Victor’s cabin! We brought our cat with us and we all got to watch the horses graze all day, had a perfect setup for fire and cooking. The bed was super comfortable and we slept amazingly. I would definitely recommend this place to others and we would love to come back and stay sometime soon. Victor and Mary were both extremely kind and welcoming, thank you for such a lovely stay!

D

Dhdnd

May 2025

Weekend Trip to Humble Farm with Simplicity

Great hospitality from Mary & Victor. The horses were friendly to my dog & I. There are also chickens on the site as well. You can tell a lot of thought was put into the cabin. It’s very homey & cozy. I stayed for one night and going to stay for more whenever I need a getaway! Recommend. :)

J

John

May 2025

Weekend Trip to Humble Farm with Simplicity

Mary and Víctor’s farm was exactly I was looking for, a place out of the city to connect with nature, Mary and Victor are an amazing hostess, I went with my dogs and they really had fun, I recommend this place, the best