Nice cabin, but not at all private
It's complicated.
Pros: Mel was so very welcoming and nice. He's a great host. The cabin itself is adorable and is very well maintained. The view, if you looked up and in the right direction, was nice. There is a short trail right off the cabin deck, with blackberries.
Cons: The cabin is right next to the Host's home. So close that we could hear the television at night.
The shared bathroom is about 10 feet from the cabin, and on the same raised platform. This means that other campers sharing it would need to walk through your site and right next to where you sleep in order to use it. It did not have any doors (just walls and and opening) so you'd have to figure out how to alert people you were going to enter, I suppose. Mel also mentioned, as we were checking in, that he rents the bathroom out to day campers and travelers in the area, by the hour. That was a surprise. We were not comfortable with the idea of that kind of traffic in our actual campsite, especially during the pandemic.
There was a memorial with a lot of garden gnomes on the edge of the campsite, which is very sweet but did feel wrong somehow, like we were intruding on something personal.
Finally, the view if you looked down consisted of a bit of a junkyard of old water or oil barrels and tubs, and other waste.
We left after one night of our three night stay. We messaged the Host to let him know, but never heard back from him.
We would not stay there again, but perhaps its a good place to stay if you don't mind being very close to other folks?