Campsite #1 itself was really nice—large, open, private, with two picnic tables and a fire ring. We also liked that it was elevated above the road.
However, we were completely alone despite the site showing the other spots as reserved, which made it feel pretty isolated and creepy at night. We heard road noise throughout the night, and having to walk down the hill to the portable restroom by the road felt uncomfortable when we were alone. We also heard animals throughout the night, which was cute but definitely made every sound feel a little more intense!
The location is another thing to consider. It’s about 25–30 minutes from Yosemite’s South Entrance, but roughly 1½ hours from Yosemite Valley and the main attractions.
Overall, beautiful and spacious during the day, but the isolation, nighttime bathroom situation, road noise, and distance to Yosemite Valley made this a mixed experience for us.